Old-Fashioned Midwestern Sweet Potato Pie

Slice of Sweet Potato Pie on plateThanksgiving will be here very soon. As of last week, much of my menu for the big meal was planned, but I was still figuring out the desserts. I wanted to make several pies, including one that was made using a hundred-year-old recipe. I flipped through several old cookbooks, and found not just one, but two recipes, for Sweet Potato Pie in a 1926 Culbertson, Nebraska cookbook.

I was immediately intrigued. I generally think of Sweet Potato Pie as a southern dessert, but based on the evidence in the old cookbook, it clearly was also popular in rural southwestern Nebraska in the early 1900’s.

Recipe for Sweet Potato Pic
Source: Methodist Ladies Aid Cook Book (Culbertson, Nebraska, 1926)
Recipe for Sweet Potato Pie
Source: Methodist Source: Ladies Aid Cook Book (Culbertson, Nebraska, 1926)

I can picture two versions of Sweet Potato Pie at a Methodist Church potluck dinner in Culbertson, each made by a cook who was very proud of her baking skills. I envision each woman (cooks were generally women back then) carefully watching as people served themselves pie, and each silently hoping that her pie was the more popular one. Which was the “winning” Culbertson recipe?

The ingredients were similar across the two recipes – though there were some differences and the ingredient amounts sometimes differed across the recipes. The first recipe called for four eggs that were separated, and the whites were beaten to stiff peaks which then was folded into the pie filling to create a light, airy mixture. The second recipe had limited directions. It called for more sugar than the first recipe, as well as for cream. It did not call for separating the eggs, so it probably made a fairly typical custard pie.

I decided that I needed to make one of these midwestern Sweet Potato Pies. I selected the first recipe for my “test run,” since I was intrigued the way the recipe called for beating the egg whites.

The recipe turned out wonderfully. The pie had a lovely light and airy texture. It had just the right amount of sweetness, and was nicely flavored with cinnamon and nutmeg. The pie reminded me a little of chiffon pies – though the filling did not contain any gelatin, so technically it was not a chiffon pie.

I put the filling in a 9-inch pie pastry.  When I put the filling in the pie shell, in order to use all of the filling, I heaped it very high (which I was able to do because of the beaten egg whites).  I worried that some would slide off the pie, but I carefully put the pie in the oven and it all stayed in place. However, if I made this pie again, I would use a 10-inch pie pan. So when I updated the recipe, I indicated that a 10-inch pie pastry should be used.

Here’s the recipe updated for modern cooks:

Midwestern Sweet Potato Pie

  • Servings: 6 - 8
  • Difficulty: moderate
  • Print

1 pound sweet potatoes (about 2 cups cooked, mashed sweet potatoes)

1/2 cup butter, softened

3/4 cup sugar

4 eggs, separated

1 teaspoon cinnamon

1 teaspoon nutmeg

1/8 teaspoon salt

juice and grated rind of 1 lemon

1 10-inch pie pastry

Step 1. Preheat oven to 425° F.

Step 2. Boil the sweet potatoes until tender, then slip the skins off, and mash. Set the mashed sweet potatoes aside.

Step 3. Put the egg whites in a bowl, then beat until fluffy and stiff. Set aside.

Step 4. Put the butter and sugar in a bowl; cream to combine.

Step  5. Add the mashed sweet potatoes, egg yolks, cinnamon, nutmeg, and salt; beat to combine.

Step 6. Stir in the lemon juice and grated lemon rind.

Step 7. Gently fold the beaten egg whites into the mixture.

Step 8. Put the pie filling into the pie pastry. If necessary, the filling can be heaped above the height of the pie shell.

Step 9. Carefully put the pie in the oven, and bake for 10 minutes.  Reduce heat to 350° F and continue baking until the filling sets and a knife inserted in the center comes out clean.

http://www.ahundredyearsago.com

2 thoughts on “Old-Fashioned Midwestern Sweet Potato Pie”

Leave a Reply