How to Get a Child to Drink Milk: 1922 Advice

glass of milk

Parents both now and a hundred years ago sometime have difficulty getting their children to drink milk. The 1922 edition of Good Housekeeping’s Book of Menus, Recipes, and Household Discoveries had the following tips:

Text about how to get a child to drink milk
Source: Good Housekeeping’s Book of Menus, Recipes, and Household Discoveries (1922)
Text about getting a child to drink milk
Source: Good Housekeeping’s Book of Menus, Recipes, and Household Discoveries (1922)

40 thoughts on “How to Get a Child to Drink Milk: 1922 Advice

        1. Oh, I do remember them. I’d totally forgotten about curved straws until you mentioned them, Looking back I wonder how we ever kept them clean – but I didn’t worry about things like that when I was a teen.

  1. The tiny glass made me laugh. My youngest did something similar. My husband brought home a shot glass that was handed out at a baseball game and left it on the counter. We later found out that our daughter had been using it for “shots” of milk. On the other hand, I don’t think lactose intolerance was widely recognized back then. Milk could have been making some children feel bad.

    1. What a fun story! I hadn’t thought about it before, but it makes sense that some children may not feel well after they drink milk because they are lactose intolerant.

  2. You should have been a post-war British child, like me. At school, we all had at morning break a bottle of milk – 1/3 of a pint – to drink through a straw, whether we liked it or not. In winter the milk was often frozen solid, and in summer, warm and cheesy. Margaret Thatcher put a stop to this in, I think, the early ’70s,hence the slogan ‘Margaret Thatcher, Milk Snatcher’.

    1. It sounds awful to have to drink frozen milk in the winter and half-spoiled milk in the summer. Times sure have changed – sometimes for the better.

  3. Yep! We were always given a big tumbler of milk – 10 -12 oz. at dinner and after eating a meal were required to finish our milk. It was torture! I’d have much preferred to have had a small glass to refill. My sons on the other hand would consume almost a gallon a day at their peak!

  4. These are certainly cute suggestions and I remember some deceptions I used with my children. I have to think that milk at that time was not what we drink today and maybe not as appealing. Although I always feel bad for children today whose parents give them 1% fat milk not only because of the taste, but because children need the full vitamins and fat from whole milk.

    1. My general sense is that milk is more standardized today. I grew up on a dairy farm and remember that the milk tasted different in the summer when the cows were out grazing in the fields than what it did in the winter.

      1. Pasteurization and homogenization processes have also changed the taste of milk. For several years my in-laws had dairy cattle and would give us milk that they had pasteurized, but I didn’t care for it (neither did my children, but the hubby loved it).

          1. My paternal grandparents only drank buttermilk as they did not care for the sweet milk. I recently switched to an organic brand in a wax carton because the taste is what I remember milk tasting like before they began putting it into plastic jugs. Like many foods, it is what we get used to!

            1. Yes, I agree, we tend to like foods when they taste like what we are used to. Your comment reminds me of how my mother used to complain about the ketchup that we bought at the store. She said that it tasted slightly burned, and that homemade ketchup tasted more like tomatoes and was much better. I’ve had homemade ketchup a few times, but didn’t appreciate it like she did. I liked commercially produced ketchup better.

  5. Interesting about the straw! I didn’t like milk as a kid, either, and as an adult, I didn’t tolerate dairy products very well, until going vegan. I just wish my parents had pursued calcium supplements…

  6. This wasn’t a problem my parents had to deal with, they had to *limit* the number of glasses we were allowed. Even so, their three daughters easily went through 8+ liters a week – I remember mom loading the grocery cart with bag after bag of the stuff. On the other hand, my sisters and I are all taller than my mother. ๐Ÿ˜‰

  7. I can relate to Winnifred, although, in kindergarten, milk cost 5 cents. I remember sitting at my desk trying to finish my carton of milk which I sipped through a straw. Though I had a straw, I still didn’t like it. ๐Ÿ™‚

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s